The Best Waterproof Eyeliner

Eyeliner delivers a lifted look that helps you fight signs of aging, create more definition, and deliver a fuller-looking lash line. While some eyeliners melt off quickly in the heat and humidity, there's a better option: waterproof eyeliner. This type of eyeliner is specially formulated to stay put from morning through night so that your makeup look lasts through it all. Read our roundup to uncover the best option for your skin type and preferences to majorly upgrade your makeup collection.

What to Look For

If you’re on the market for a new waterproof eyeliner, consider three important things before making your final decision: the application method, the staying power, and the quality of the ingredients. The NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink eyeliner is our favorite all-around option. It is very pigmented, easy to apply, and lasts all day for a true triple-threat product. The Honest Beauty eyeliner, on the other hand, may not deliver to same longevity but is crafted from eco-friendly and natural ingredients that make it a safer alternative to many other cosmetics. Explore these two eyeliners and our other favorites below.

NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Waterproof Eyeliner

A fine line

This liquid eyeliner provides a bold, long-lasting look.
Best Overall

Find on Amazon

This ultra-black eyeliner will quickly become your new go-to makeup product. The super-fine tip gives you maximum control to achieve any look, from a thin, subtle line to a bold cat-eye. Formulated to last all day, the waterproof product can be used on your upper lash line, lower lashes, or outer corners and will stay put through it all. It’s also a cruelty-free liner that isn’t tested on animals, so it’s a good choice for animal-conscious consumers.

Pros:

  • It’s incredibly affordable, not to mention effective. In fact, it arguably delivers the same quality as brands twice as expensive.
  • Because it creates a very crisp, clean line, you won’t have to worry about unevenness, splotchy application, or broken lines.

Cons:

  • This liner isn’t the best option if you have hooded eyes because it may smudge before it dries.

Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen Waterproof Eyeliner

Thick and thin

This felt-tip liner gives you maximum control to achieve any style.
Runner Up

Find on Amazon

If you’re searching for a new everyday eyeliner, look no further. This versatile liquid formula creates a thin, even line to help you achieve a flawless finish. The hexagon-shaped tube ensures you have a sure and steady grip. This means that you’ll have added control as you apply, making it easier to achieve a smooth line every time. It also has a flexible brush tip to make the application stress-free, even if you’re going for a winged look or dramatic cat-eye.

Pros:

  • The formula is very pigmented, so you’ll get an opaque, solid black line for a bolder look.
  • Even if you have fine lines or wrinkles, this liner goes on smooth so it’s perfect for people of all ages and skin types.

Cons:

  • It can dry out quickly, so be sure to put the cap back on properly to preserve moisture.

Revlon Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner

Pencil me in

This waterproof eyeliner pencil goes on silky smooth.
Best Pencil Design

Find on Amazon

If you want a pencil eyeliner with all-day staying power, this is your perfect product. The waterproof formula makes it possible to apply first thing in the morning and still have fresh-faced and smudge-free makeup at the end of the day. Available in a wide range of different shades for a customizable look, it even has a built-in sharpener so you always have a precise point to work with. Try using it to create a subtle, smoky look or even a bold cat-eye. The options are nearly endless.

Pros:

  • The silky-smooth formula ensures that this eyeliner easily glides on, so you don’t have to tug or pull at the sensitive area around your eyes to get a clean line.
  • Even if you have oily skin, the eyeliner stays in place all day. It’s a versatile option that works for almost every skin type.

Cons:

  • The tip of the pencil can break off easily, so you might have to sharpen it a lot, which can add extra time to your getting-ready routine.

Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Eye Liner Pencil

Draw the line

This waterproof eyeliner will level up your makeup collection without breaking the bank.
Best On A Budget

Find on Amazon

This eyeliner can help achieve a sultry, smokier look around the eyes. The gel formula is the perfect middle ground between a pencil and a liquid, helping you get a smooth, creamy line. It’s also highly pigmented, so just a single swipe will deliver an opaque look for a dark and defined line without the hassle.

Pros:

  • Even if you have oily skin, this eyeliner won’t smudge. It has amazing staying power and can withstand hours and hours of wear.
  • This eyeliner has been approved by ophthalmologists, making it a safe option for both contact lens wearers and those with sensitive eyes.

Cons:

  • The formula is so waterproof that it can be hard to correct mistakes. As a result, it’s best for those who have a lot of experience applying eyeliner.

Honest Beauty Liquid Eyeliner

Au naturale

This cruelty-free vegan eyeliner is an excellent eco-friendly option.
Best Vegan Eyeliner

Find on Amazon

This silicone-free eyeliner will last up to eight hours, delivering flawless, all-day makeup. The vegan, cruelty-free formula glides on smoothly thanks to the felt-tip applicator, giving you ultimate control and precision. A satin finish also offers a silky, slightly shiny look that gives your makeup an unbeatable glow. Try it for yourself to see the difference.

Pros:

  • It dries very quickly, so you don’t have to worry about accidental smudges or smears.
  • In addition to being vegan and cruelty-free, the eyeliner is also free of parabens, pigment, silicone, and PEGS, making it the ideal option for those with sensitive eyes or allergies.

Cons:

  • If you have hooded eyes, this formula may not be the best option because it could transfer onto eyelids more easily.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is waterproof eyeliner bad for the eyes?

When applied properly, waterproof eyeliner is not dangerous for your eyes. Just be sure to apply the product only to your lash line — and never on your waterline — to ensure the formula doesn’t irritate your eyes by blocking your oil glands or tear ducts.

How do I remove waterproof eyeliner?

Makeup remover is often the most effective way to remove waterproof makeup. First, soak a cotton pad with oil-based makeup remover. Then, gently wipe your eye area to remove waterproof eyeliner, mascara, and any other makeup. Once removed, cleanse your face as normal.

Can I use waterproof eyeliner with mascara?

Yes. Pairing waterproof eyeliner with waterproof mascara is a smart choice, especially in warm or humid weather. Pairing the two together can help you achieve a smudge-free makeup look that lasts all day. Just be sure to avoid using waterproof eyeliner and mascara if you have eyelash extensions, as it can dissolve the glue and cause extensions to fall out quickly.

About the Author

Hannah knows all about what it means to find makeup, skincare, and haircare products that are right for you. Her goal is to help everyone find the ones that work for them and that bring their desired looks to life. After many years of trial and error, Hannah has finally built her own personal beauty routines, and she hopes to help everyone find theirs.

Why Trust Us

Since 2007, TotalBeauty has been committed to helping millions of people find the right makeup, skincare, and haircare products for their needs. Our experts know what works best for every face shape, skin type, hair type, and more. They are here to share that knowledge with everyone looking to upgrade their beauty routines or try something new.